Civil and criminal cases often get treated as the same thing with different names, but they are separate legal paths that serve different purposes and follow different rules. Many survivors assume that if police do not make an arrest or a prosecutor decides not to file charges, the matter is simply over. That assumption can stop someone from ever learning about an option that exists independently of anything the criminal system decides to do.
This piece looks at how civil and criminal cases differ, what a civil case can accomplish that a criminal case cannot, and what your options look like even when no criminal charges were ever filed. None of it requires a criminal case to already be underway, or to have happened at all.
Most people’s understanding of the justice system comes from criminal trials portrayed in the news or on television, which makes the civil side feel unfamiliar by comparison. Filing a California sexual assault claim in civil court means following a different process, with different goals and a different person deciding whether it moves forward. Understanding that distinction early on tends to clear up a lot of confusion about what options remain open.
The confusion is understandable given how tightly the two systems are described together in everyday conversation. A criminal case addresses whether a crime was committed against the state and what punishment should follow, while options for filing a civil claim exist separately to address harm done to an individual. They can overlap in the same set of facts without depending on each other in any way.
The biggest difference between the two systems comes down to who actually holds the decision-making power at each stage.
A prosecutor, not the survivor, decides whether to file criminal charges, and that decision can turn on factors that have little to do with whether the assault happened. Evidence falling short of the criminal standard, witness availability, or simply the volume of cases moving through a prosecutor’s office can affect the outcome. A survivor has no direct control over that process and no ability to compel a prosecutor to bring charges.
A civil claim works differently because it is the survivor, working with a civil sexual abuse attorney, who decides whether to file it, when to file it, and whether to settle or continue toward trial. That control does not disappear partway through the process the way it effectively does once a criminal case is in a prosecutor’s hands.
A criminal conviction can result in jail time or probation, and the court can order the offender to repay certain losses, such as therapy, medical care, or lost income. In most cases, though, criminal restitution does not cover pain and suffering. A civil case exists to address that fuller harm, seeking compensation directly from the person or institution responsible rather than a punishment carried out by the state.
Civil cases can also reach parties a criminal prosecution often cannot, including an employer, school, or organization whose negligence allowed the abuse to happen. For survivors weighing their options, this broader reach is often what makes a civil claim worth pursuing even when a criminal case has concluded, gone nowhere, or never started at all.
Criminal cases require proof beyond a reasonable doubt, the highest standard used anywhere in the legal system, because a conviction can take away someone’s freedom. Civil cases use a lower standard known as a preponderance of the evidence, meaning the claim only has to be more likely true than not. That difference in standard is a major reason a case that did not result in criminal charges can still succeed in civil court.
This is not a loophole or a lesser version of justice. It reflects the fact that civil and criminal cases ask courts to decide different questions, with different consequences attached to getting the answer wrong, and the law applies different levels of proof depending on what is at stake for the person being accused.
A decision by police or a prosecutor not to pursue criminal charges says nothing about whether a civil claim can move forward. Sexual assault claims pursued without criminal charges are common enough that a civil suit is understood to stand on its own, because the two cases answer separate legal questions under separate rules of proof.
This matters because so many survivors never learn it. Believing that a lack of criminal charges closes every door keeps people from exploring whether a civil claim might still be available to them, sometimes until the deadline to file has already passed.
A criminal case and a civil case can move forward at the same time, and it is fairly common for a civil claim to be filed while a criminal matter is still pending or after it has already concluded, although a court may pause parts of the civil case, such as discovery, until the criminal case is resolved. The outcome of one does not automatically decide the outcome of the other, since they operate under different standards and different rules entirely.
Some survivors choose to wait until a criminal case has resolved before starting a civil claim, while others move forward with both at the same time. There is no single right order, and the choice often comes down to personal comfort and the specifics of the situation.
Privacy protections remain available throughout a civil case, including options to proceed under a pseudonym in many jurisdictions so a survivor’s name does not appear in public court filings. Courts generally weigh a survivor’s privacy and safety interests seriously when this kind of protection is requested in a case involving sexual abuse.
Starting with a private first conversation lets you ask what privacy protections would look like in your specific situation before any decision is made about moving forward. Nothing about exploring a civil claim requires giving up control over your own story.
Speak With a Sexual Assault Justice Expert Today
A criminal case belongs to the state, and many survivors are surprised to learn they can bring a civil case of their own. Dordulian Law Group can explain what a civil case can achieve and pursue the justice and compensation you deserve, with your privacy protected throughout. All calls are confidential.
Visit us at one of our offices:
Or call now for a free consultation on (866) GO-SEE-SAM ((866) GO-SEE-SAM).
Author
"*" indicates required fields
